Apr 21, 2004 if you want to go the esri route you can get a good deal on arcmap with a year of support through a donation and membership to imta. Manifold has a decidedly different software model than esri and the only other gis program ive used transcad. Since this question was put on hold i have attempted to bring it back on topic by editing it. Id be grateful for any constructive criticism of the above commentary, as my intent is, within the context of my strong personal opinions, to highlight fairly what i see to be the main differences between esris approach and manifolds approach. Solve challenges in managing fiber cabling infrastructure in both inside and outside plant. Manifold delivers blistering speed with rocksolid reliability. Manifold system handles both vector and raster data, includes spatial sql, a builtin internet map server ims, and other general gis features.
System requirements for arcgis for desktop, including supported operating systems, os limitations, hardware and software requirements, and the license manager and developer sdk requirements are provided. Some comments on previous comparisons have stated that manifold was so super fast compared to esri because tests were run on a highend, threadripper machine that could run 48 threads. With the help of capterra, learn about manifold gis, its features, pricing. Jan 29, 2016 manifold imports data from over 80 different gis formats, including all formats used by federal government sites for free internet downloads, and manifold allows seamless, simultaneous work with vector drawings, raster images, terrain elevations and raster data sets either as 2d displays or 3d terrain visualizations. A gis light basic gis for beginners although a good option for beginners a novelty gis package is. Manifold system is a geographic information system gis software package developed by manifold. Manifold gis is a combination of mapping, cad, dbms and image processing. We should aim to document any special interoperability with openstreetmap for each gis software package on the relevant wiki pages linked below, but in general terms, openstreetmap data is open.
Manifold has some very good features, especially the price. Manifold vs arcgis arc gis geographic information system. It can not be imported in any software directly, user has to export its vector or raster layers. Aug 10, 2011 software like manifold is inexpensive but their customer service is pitiful and, as other posters have indicated, their update schedule is more a wish than a reality. Feb 12, 2009 some of the analysis features are brilliant and extremely easy to use. Some alternative products to manifold gis include munilogic, govpilot, and jibestream. May 27, 2007 manifold contains inbuilt internet map server ims for publishing gis maps on web. With the help of capterra, learn about manifold gis, its features, pricing information, popular comparisons to other gis products and more. Both are big packages so a comparison necessarily has to stick to rough summaries. See manifold do in 11 seconds what takes esris arcgis pro over 20 minutes. Feb 11, 2020 some comments on previous comparisons have stated that manifold was so super fast compared to esri because tests were run on a highend, threadripper machine that could run 48 threads.
Calculating euclidean distances around barriers is a brand new feature in esris spatial analyst, so cool and useful that manifold has implemented euclidean computations around barriers as well, but in fully parallelized form that runs significantly faster than spatial analyst, typically taking 7 seconds for what requires a. If the arcgis for desktop setup does not find either python 2. Software like manifold is inexpensive but their customer service is pitiful and, as other posters have indicated, their update schedule is more a wish than a reality. Open source platform with powerful location intelligence and analysis capabilities for businesses analysts, data scientists as well as the individual users. Id be grateful for any constructive criticism of the above commentary, as my intent is, within the context of my strong personal opinions, to highlight fairly what i see to be the main differences between esri s approach and manifold s approach. Comparison of geographic information systems software. Arcgis might be expensive but the support is great and their user community is large. Manifold system, no, no, yes, no, no, no, no, yes, no. Manifold viewer is a readonly subset of manifold release 9.
I also felt that limiting the conversation to only desktop software, and only allowing answers from people that do use arcgis products was hurting the questions viability and objectivity. The choice for procuring particular gis software depends on kind of gis tasks to be done and the budget available. Notable commercial or proprietary gis software unggim. Manifold gis is gis software, and includes features such as image management, spatial analysis, color coding, map sharing, and internet mapping. And with this revelation that qgis which is free can do virtually all that can be done using very expensive esri gis software arcgis, qgis popularity will surely rise to become the default gis software of the striving countries of the world. To be included on this list, the software must have a linked existing article.
Esri quality used to be much lower, with esri people writing web pages for each other about how to deal with crashes, while manifold has always been famously bulletproof, but esri s quality. Manifold combines the visual and spatial power of gis with the massive data science power of builtin parallel dbms. Benefits of integrating gis and hydraulic modeling esri. Manifold system is a geographic information system gis software package developed by that runs on microsoft windows. Esri now have their own 3d analyst and spatial analyst extensions which perform many of the same functions, however discover and discover 3d still beat to them to the pip in terms of geology data processing. Manifold software faster gis, etl and database tools. The system enables you to produce maps and graphs of geographic info for presentation and analysis. The spatial index for a shapefile is inefficient compared. Esri arcgis products are designed to deliver location intelligence and meet digital transformation needs for organizations of all sizes.
Manifold vs arc fifty times faster than spatial analyst youtube. Arguably any software which works with map data can be called gis software, but the term is often associated with a breed of powerful traditional software packages, running as desktop applications, with rich mature feature sets which have been around long before openstreetmap existed also see wikipedia about gis applications. Esri gis products arcgis mapping software for desktop, saas. Arcgis server is the core server geographic information system gis software made by esri. Here we will be discussing two software arcgis and manifold. I realize that there are a lot of challenges inherent in providing gpu processing support across all platforms, but even if esri could put in partial support just for windows in arcmap or something of that sort, it would be great.
Thats just general wisdom in the atmosphere, because of huge numbers of companies and government departments and educational institutions that have deployed esri software en masse. Manifold system release 8 delivers the worlds most powerful, most fullfeatured classic geographic information system gis package as a fullyintegrated application at an astonishingly low price. Manifolds loyal user base has been promised the massively faster and improved manifold 9, but there has been no sign of this new release in 2 years. There is no bias for these or any other gis software. Manifold vs arc 100x faster on an affordable desktop. A full, very comprehensive gis package a very valuable addition to any gis tool set a scalable gis. Learn how businesses are using location intelligence to gain competitive advantage. Both manifold and esri products are large products with thousands of pages of documentation for the full product suite of either. A shapefile may take three to five times as much space as a file geodatabase or sde because of shape compression methods. It can not be imported in any software directly, user has to export its vector or raster layers in standard gis format using manifold itself. In general, its set up more like a combination of gis and graphic design software than simply a gis. Pro has nearly all of the capabilities of its predecessor arcgis desktop a.
Data sources manifold software gis and database tools. Allows the creation of thematic maps quickly, easily geoprocessing tools allows integration with most database managers support to edit spatial attributes and data and integrate the base tables of maps with. I, like many manifold users, are beginning to despair of any development of the software. The other product we have been considering is arcgis server.
Arcgis pro is the current desktop gis software from esri. The hallmark of gis is the power of using a visual interface to view, grab, analyze, manipulate and transform data that would not be comprehensible in classic row and column dbms text presentations. Manifold delivers blistering speed with rocksolid reliability, even with big data. Comparison of gis software gis wiki the gis encyclopedia. To be included on this list, the software must have. If i recall correctly, only creation of mrsid files up to 50mb is free of charge, beyond that you need a lizardtech. We map out the gis software landscape and list 30 options for you to choose from. Lembos work when he did a very systematic job of how to do the same routine with arcgis and manifold. Manifold gis is a software package that performs spatial data inspection and analysis. Typically, the gis database is likely to be more uptodate than a utilitys hydraulic model, since gis supports a variety of applications mapping, planning, spatial analysis, asset management, etc. Calculating euclidean distances around barriers is a brand new feature in esri s spatial analyst, so cool and useful that manifold has implemented euclidean computations around barriers as well, but in fully parallelized form that runs significantly faster than spatial analyst, typically taking 7 seconds for what requires a full. Manifold contains inbuilt internet map server ims for publishing gis maps on web.
To the right is indicated if its done or not by manifold gis. More than the comparative sense i was struck by the number of separated actions by subject that results in a. Add support and integration for the manifold gis software. Manifold culture tends to be a highly rtfmoriented culture as well. Mapinfo has for a long time been the only competitor to esri in the professional gis market. Most people know esri software, and most people whove heard of gis think of esri. For a gallery of youtube videos, including spectacular demonstrations of manifold speed, visit the videos page for a gallery of manifold system release 8. In addition it has a pretty powerful extension language in mapbasic. In short proper use of gdal open formats and storage options like tiled tiff with a proper compression is very very good, still compact and a save and interoperable way to go. Esri builds the leading mapping and spatial analytics software for desktop, software as a service saas, and enterprise applications.
Hi all, our department is currently using map guide 6. Viewer can browse and analyze, but not modify, databases. There have really only been 4 major changesadditions in esri software architecture in 40 years arcinfo, arcview. Policy and authorize software advice to use automated means to call, text or email me. Here you can explore esri software, apps, content, solutions, and. The comparison is based on a matrix that separates the normal use integration routines, please note, it isnt based on manifolds routines but in the arcgis. I have no desire to use manifold i would prefer to use arcmap, arccatalog, or geoprocessing tasks on arcgis server. To protect my business and keep ahead of the game i am being forced to look for other gis solutions. This page provides screen shots for manifold release 9 and manifold viewer, fullyparallel gis products based on manifolds radian parallel technology videos. However, before we do this we are weighing all of our options. Manifold vs arc contour lines 11 seconds vs 20 minutes. Geographic information system gis software is designed to analyze, display, manage, store, and retrieve all kinds of spatial and geographic data. Thank you to for this wonderful and informative article.
If you want to go the esri route you can get a good deal on arcmap with a year of support through a donation and membership to imta. Esri gis products arcgis mapping software for desktop. Its just a titanic work which has made by a manifolds user called tomasfa and that has been uploaded to that tools forum. There have also been a number of rants recently and i wanted to provide a space for reasoned opinions as. Allowing fme to interact with manifold directly as well as its. Thanks to the dedicated team of thousands of software developers and product engineers at esri who make arcgis work. The main concern with this software is its format i. See manifold technology in action watch the gulf bathymetry youtube video of manifold viewer opening a project file in 110th second that the us government website providing the data warned will take esri software 30 minutes to open in the equivalent esri native format.
Current esri software users that are trying out manifold will be able to relate to his reaction to using manifold. Manifold imports data from over 80 different gis formats, including all formats used by federal government sites for free internet downloads, and manifold allows seamless, simultaneous work with vector drawings, raster images, terrain elevations and raster data sets either as 2d displays or 3d terrain visualizations. Cuda gpu support geonet, the esri community gis and. May 26, 2007 the choice for procuring particular gis software depends on kind of gis tasks to be done and the budget available. We usually need that as gis professionals for different purposes, benchmarking the software, justify the choice to our boss, explain why choose manifold over the competition and how can a low cost software can do so much. Business software downloads manifold system by cda international and many more programs are available for instant and free download. Qgis or arcgis which is better for beginners in gis. Viewer cannot save projects and viewer cannot write or export data to any format or link data sources in readwrite mode. Manifold system is a geographic information system gis software package developed by manifold software limited that runs on microsoft windows. Manifold software is a software company and offers a software product called manifold gis.
Manifold creates contour lines in 11 seconds for a 26000 x 38000 terrain elevation raster, with arcgis pro taking 20. Shapefiles and postgis databases can be createdpopulated with openstreetmap data. Shapefiles support multipatches but lack support for the following advanced multipatch capabilities. Viewer can display, but not edit, files such as shapefiles, databases such as oracle, sql server, mysql, postgresql, ibm db2, esri gdb, etc.
Arcgis pro is great software that esri introduced a few years ago as their new flagship gis. The gis software competes with esri and mapinfo gis products. We compare manifold release 9 to esris arcmap with spatial analyst. Manifold vs arc euclidean barriers 7 seconds vs 1 minute. Arcgis and manifold gis comparison autocad software. Some of the analysis features are brilliant and extremely easy to use. While perhaps missing some of the cartography features of arcgis desktop advanced arcinfo it is very capable and has a smaller price tag. Comparison of geographic information systems software wikipedia.
1546 632 1143 719 1578 117 256 507 1213 96 1680 77 411 58 430 1642 107 1432 1117 584 1547 1294 1341 1145 1241 740 859 1570 905 149 880 591 785 7 894